High Court finds in favour of ASIC on an appeal by Sunshine Loans
court order18 Mar 2026
Respondent
Sunshine Loans
Facts
ASIC has been successful in the High Court on an appeal by Sunshine Loans from a decision of the Full Federal Court concerning the decision made by the liability judge to recuse himself from determining the question of penalty, with the High Court finding 7-0 in ASIC’s favour.
Outcome
High Court of Australia unanimously dismissed Sunshine Loans' appeal (2026-03-18) on whether the Federal Court liability judge, who in April 2024 found Sunshine Loans charged unlawful fees under the National Credit Act, should be recused from deciding penalty. The penalty is still to be determined. See the ASIC source for the full terms.